This page is a gallery of the most recurring characters in the fanmade series.[]
In order to be on this page, the character has to be suspected in 10 or more cases.
- Gus Washington (29 Cases)
- Fabian Marc-Holmann (24 Cases)
- Ronda Warner (18 Cases)
- Kim Krause (18 Cases)
- King K. (18 Cases)
- Mike Patterson (16 Cases)
- Ricky Hernandez (15 Cases)
- Walton Bartlett (15 Cases)
- Wynston Hammacher (14 Cases)
- Yazid Shams (14 Cases)
- Kieran Bartlett (13 Cases)
- Sophia Bartlett (12 Cases)
- Bridget Luders (12 Cases)
- Susie Brown (12 Cases)
- Mary Thompson (12 Cases)
- Arnav Singhal (12 Cases)
- Amber Montoya (11 Cases)
- Sara Lopez (11 Cases)
- Michael Patterson (10 Cases)
- Tycen Joyner (10 Cases)
- Spencer Fleming (10 Cases)
- Christopher Knap (10 Cases)
- Monty Wildzap (10 Cases)
- Maryell Charles (10 Cases)
- Jediel Andujar (10 Cases)
- Tom Fisher (10 Cases)
- Finn Tucker (10 Cases)
- Elliot Ponzi (10 Cases)
Honorable Mentions[]
The following are suspects in 9 different cases.
- Anna Bommarito (9 Cases)
- Xazath (9 Cases)
- Hoover Dawson (9 Cases)
- Evelyn Tarik (9 Cases)